This map takes us from one shadow to another- "Shadows in the Dark" through "Shadows in Zamboula." That was not at all intentional. 1. "Shadows in the Dark" begins in Khoraja's capital of the same name. Conan travels around Khorshemish in Koth for plot reasons.
2. Conan and his compatriots rescue King Khossus in Ianthe, Ophir. Realizing that one of his party is a traitor, he makes the journey to Messantia with just himself and the king. 3. Conan leaves Khossus in Messantia, stealing most of his gold pretty hilariously in the process. He puts the king on a ship and then jumps back to shore as it pulls away. Curiously, he travels an extremely far distance over land between this story and the next, which seems odd. I feel like that's a huge distance to cover, especially since it's said that Conan's about 30 and is only "about 31" in "Black Tears," but I'm not sure if there's a better placement for any of these stories. I know the William Galen Gray chronology puts "The Road of Kings after "Shadows in the Dark," but I don't know if that story ends closer to Turan, because the net says it's mostly a pirate story and I haven't done much research into it. 4. "Shadows in the Moonlight" picks up very, very far away on the Vilayet Sea, with Conan going to a nameless isle of iron statues. He leaves it at the end of the story and sails away with the Red Brotherhood. 5. Conan arrives on the coast of the Vilayet with the Red Brotherhood at the beginning of "The Road of the Eagles." They enter the nearby mountain range and attack a castle near the Yuetshi village. 6. "A Witch Shall Be Born" takes place almost entirely in Khauran or outside of it. 7. "Black Tears," about a year after "A Witch Shall Be Born," takes place in the desert and specifically the area known as the Red Waste. Conan goes to the desert city of Akhlat and the story ends with him leaving there. The line between Khauran and this really shouldn't be a straight line since the prologues states, "After the events narrated in "A Witch Shall Be Born", Conan leads his band of Zuagirs eastward to raid the cities and caravans of the Turanians" but I'm not going to muck up the map with a bunch of squiggles that represent nearly a year. 8. "Shadows in Zamboula" takes place in Zamboula. Conan is there about a week, with the story taking place over the course of one night.
0 Comments
At the beginning of "Shadows in Zamboula," Conan has been in the desert city of Zamboula for about a week and has gambled or drank away any money he had. A fellow Zaugir raider tells him that the inn Conan has chosen to sleep at is cursed: people check in, but they're never seen again after that and their belongings are sold in nearby shops. A real "Hotel California" situation. Conan, of course, doesn't find a new inn at which to stay. He goes to the house of Aman Baksh, the allegedly cursed inn, and is shown to his room, which is pretty plush for the price he paid. Satisfied that the windows are secure and the door is locked, he drifts off to sleep, but not before noting that he's a little bit more perturbed by the raider's story than he had been in the daylight. Of course, he's awakened to a would-be assailant (who's gotten in because of a secret latch outside his door!) that Conan is able to fend off. Because of the whole "Man-Eater" title, I was initially kind of excited. I was reminded of the quests in Fallout: New Vegas revolving around the White Glove Society and the Ultra-Luxe casino, with the weirdo, ultra-rich cannibals. That's where the fun ends, though. This story is truly tainted by the way Robert E. Howard seethes with racist vitriol in nearly every description afterword. He imbues every corner of this story with dripping, contemptuous racial hatred. He takes every opportunity to describe the Black men of this story as misshapen, guttural, stupid, sluggish, ape-like, cannibalistic, cultish, and subhuman. You get the sense that he feels very strongly that the enslaved state the men are in this story is their natural state. Howard others the Jewish-coded characters as "hook-nosed" and always described their beards as not only black in color, but "blue-black," for some weird reason. He's even weirdly off-putting about the race of white characters in this story. As he did in "The Vale of Lost Women," he also writes Conan worse than normal, passing all his prejudices onto the Cimmerian. It's truly disgusting. Avoid this story- there are no redeeming qualities. It's not like it has unsavory elements that can be looked over; the whole thing is just vile. I'd be very happy to see this story never printed again. Much has been written about Howard's cruel views on other human beings, thankfully challenged by his girlfriend, who was a teacher. In regards to this story, some people have said that they feel it's better because Howard only considers some Black folks to match the descriptions I wrote above. Some internet Conan fans, ones I have enjoyed reading and using as research for this blog before, have bafflingly not even mentioned it at all (one page says "Robert E. Howard was really on top of his game" with this one and that it was "[their] kind of Conan story, highly recommended." Fuuuuuck that). I genuinely wish I had something productive or very thoughtful to add to this story that is a regrettable relic of it's time. I really don't. The cover of Savage Sword 14 for Roy Thomas's adaption is pretty good, I suppose. Norem never misses, even if the story is dogshit. "The Star of Khorala" is up next and is thankfully much better. ★☆☆☆☆ "Black Tears," written by L. Sprague de Camp and Lin Carter, is a direct sequel to "A Witch Shall Be Born." It first appeared in Conan the Wanderer in 1968. Much of the time, the chronological cues we get about where a story takes place in Conan's life are limited to the little prologues that de Camp and Carter write. Those precede the story and set it in time (with the exception of "The Frost-Giant's Daughter," which I disagreed with them on their placement). They can be helpful. Sometimes within a story, we get a vague listing of the things Conan has done in his life up to that point. However, the actual body text of "Black Tears" sets it about a year after "Witch." "For years now, this outlaw band had harried and looted towns and trading posts and caravan stations along the borders of Turan--first under that black-hearted Zaporoskan rogue, Olgerd Vladislav; then, a little more than a year ago, by his successor, Conan." If Conan is commanding something within a story, I happen to like the stories in which he's commanding outlaw bands or pirates as opposed to large, well-funded armies. It seems to suit his character a little better seeing as he has a distaste for "civilized" society. Honestly, that distaste has a tendency to come and go as Conan really seems to enjoy wine and women in a palace, at least for a while before he tires of it. Either way, it's more fun to root for the rogueish underdog than someone commanding a military force. In the prologue of this story, it says that Conan is about 31 years old and is at the height of his physical powers. He's spent his time recently raiding the Turanian countryside (which I think is rather interesting, going from two years as a celebrated asset of the Turanian army to a total thorn in their side). Overall, "Black Tears" is alright. I rated it pretty high when I initially read it, but looking back, I think that's partially just because "Witch" was somewhat of a bummer. It is, though, paced much, much better than "A Witch Shall Be Born," which made it fly by with a lot breezier of a pace than its direct predecessor. It's interesting that the previous story had so many Biblical ties (which I didn't write about since I didn't really have anything to add- there are other writers and bloggers out there who've said quite a bit about "Witch's" Biblical stuff if you're interested) and this story has Conan wandering the desert like another mythical figure who happened to get crucified, just in the opposite order). When he stumbles into Akhlat in the Red Waste and Enosh there tells him that they feed people to the gorgon to suck their life-force out, I was pretty horrified. According to Gary Romeo over at Sprage de Camp Fan, the prose of this one should mostly be credited to Lin Carter rather than de Camp, as a letter between the collaborating authors would show. The gorgon was fun. I only recently learned what a gorgon was when I watched the Hammer horror film The Gorgon a couple of months ago. I'm a big Hammer guy. Anyway, the descriptions of the human forest of stone in the gorgon's chamber were pretty excellent.
Like a lot of people, it was art that initially drew me to Conan the Barbarian. There are so many incredible artists who have worked on Conan for the last 90 years that he's been done in dozens of styles and mediums. There have been specific scenes from his best-known stories reproduced on canvas and originals that evoke the spirit of our favorite Cimmerian. I wanted to spend some time appreciating those artists who have brought him to life in such meaningful ways. I love Conan art, but I'm not an art critic or much of an artist by any stretch of the imagination, so I enlisted my twin brother Jake to help me out here. Jake's actually an artist and a professional designer, so I wanted to see what he thought about various Conan artists and was hoping he'd let me know if I was talking out of my ass. Much of this will be about cover artists of Savage Sword of Conan, and while there is frequently incredible interior art in Conan comics (Barry Windsor-Smith, Ernie Chan, Sal and John Buscema, and Val Mayerik, just to name a few), I want to focus on the paintings and covers that draw us to those stories. Frank Frazetta
Earl Norem
Boris Vallejo
Margaret Brundage
Neal Adams
Bob Larkin
Nestor Redondo
Joe Jusko
David Mattingly
Joe Chiodo
Bill Sienkiewicz
Vladimir Nenov
Ken Kelly
While we were talking about Kelly's work, Jake made a little graphic to highlight how much of Kelly's paintings are essentially negative space. He drained the color out of everything except the foreground in the collage below. He says that he feels Conan is usually in-your-face, but Kelly is so much more restrained, putting him off-center in the frame and including a little more narrative in his work since he's giving you more to look at. When Savage Sword switches title fonts at issue 207, I think it's a huge travesty. So many of the works of the artists above look amazing right beneath the vicious SAVAGE SWORD text and the big, blocky CONAN. I'm not a huge fan of the logo they've been using on the 2024 Titan run, but it's better than the last 30 issues of volume 1's cover. If you've made it this far, thanks for checking out these great artists with us! Go follow my brother on social media if you want to check out his work- he does great albums, concert posters, photography, and just little fun designs that he comes up with.
According to the Conan Wiki, "A Witch Shall Be Born" was banged out by Robert E. Howard in just a couple of days. That's not necessarily a bad thing; I loved the one-draft "Rogues in the House." But while writing "A Witch Shall Be Born," Howard's novel, The Hour of the Dragon, wasn't headed for Weird Tales and "The People of the Black Circle" was already scheduled for the August issue. So editor Farnsworth Wright didn't have any new Conan adventures on his desk, and he wanted something to put into the publishing pipeline. When Howard sent "Witch" off to Wright, he said it was Howard's best Conan story yet and it made the cover of the December Weird Tales. Gotta disagree with you there, Mr. Wright. Like, "A Witch Shall Be Born" is fine, but definitely not a top-ranking Conan story. This story follows "The Road of the Eagles," at least according to de Camp's introduction in Conan the Freebooter, and I think it makes sense. Conan is in his kozaki period as a sort of outlaw raider, and this is the third story of that section, following "Iron Shadows in the Moon" and "The Road of the Eagles." He's traveled a long way, moving east, and has once again gained everyone's respect through his fighting ability. I feel like we've reached quite the pattern here that whenever Conan joins up with a new group of people, he quickly becomes their leader because he's the most shrewd, cool-headed, physically-capable of all of them. He takes command of the zuagir raiders from Olgerd Vladislav in this story, and will spend about a year amongst the zuagirs if "A Probable Outline of Conan's Career" is accurate. Olgerd is a decent villain, and while Howard didn't do too much with the guy, it seems that many other authors liked working with the character, because he's the source of several stories in Savage Sword that try to explain what happened to him after this tale. They all contradict each other immensely. We open in Khauran. The opening dialogue between Queen Taramis and her evil twin sister Salome is fun and actually has room to breathe. It takes up a lot more ink than most dialogue scenes Howard wrote. I'm an identical twin and I like this one, not just because one of our college professors dubbed me the evil twin and calls me that to this day, but because it's quite the saga for a Howard dialogue scene. Following this opening is one of the most iconic scenes in all of the Conan canon, the tree of death, which has Conan crucified on a wooden X in the desert. Yes, as everyone agrees, this scene absolutely rips and there's a reason why it's so well known and why it made it into the movie. The rest of the story never really comes together, though. Salome is being evil, Conan usurps Olgerd Vladislav, they take the city and rescue Taramis. I'm far from the first person to point out how awkward and somewhat jarring it is to have the story interrupted by a Nemedian scholar to just sort of tell us about the decline of Khauran under Salome's rule, even if it is Howard trying something new. Conan crucifying Constantius at the end is a decent end to the story, as Conan rejects the role of royal counselor from Taramis and returns to the desert. "A Witch Shall Be Born" might actually be more interesting in what it says about Howard than the adventures contained within. According to Patrice Louinet's "Hyborian Genesis" essay, "Witch" is something of a victory lap for REH: "Conan, in A Witch Shall Be Born, is becoming a superhuman character. Howard was growing extremely confident with his creation as testifies the structure of the tale. We are here miles away from pulp formula: Conan—the protagonist—gives life to the entire story by being present in only two chapters. It is tempting to draw a parallel between Conan and what Howard thought he was achieving with the Conan series: The Texan knew he had a winner and that he could get away with almost everything, even not having the lead character in the story except in the central chapters.
"The Road of the Eagles" is one of the four Conanless Robert E. Howard stories that L. Sprague de Camp pulled from Howard's fragments and plans in the early 50s and preceded to inject Conan into. It's the only one of the four that kept it's original title. Sort of. The original version, a story set in Turkey at the end of the 16th century, was actually sold for publishing during Howard's lifetime, but the magazine went out of business before the pages went public so it was effectively still an unpublished story. de Camp added Conan to its plot and some little vampire-goblin fellas for the climax and it appeared as "Conan, Man of Destiny" (tremendously awful title) in the December 1955 Fantastic Universe issue. When it was republished in Conan the Freebooter, it got its original title back. In 1979, Howard's original story (without Conan) was published and was re-christened The Way of the Swords, which is not as completelyfuckingterrible as "Man of Destiny" but is still pretty bad. de Camp did a good job with this one. Despite there being too much of an exposition dump in the first few pages, "Eagles" is a seriously thrilling story. Conan and his Red Brotherhood pirates are in the mountains by the sea and attack a castle that has been carved out of sheer rock into a mountainside. There is a secret-passageway backroad to the castle, which leads to a single door in the side of the wall, and the way there is filled danger. Seeing the Turanians tie a rope to the door and shimmy over chasms to get to the only opening to the castle is just awesome, I can't think of a better word for it. Once the action begins, the story never stops rolling. I get the feeling that I like "The Road of the Eagles" way more than most Conan fans, but I'll go to bat for this story. Of the ratings I've been doing in this chronology, it's the first time I wish I could give out half-stars, because I'd love to give it four and a half. It's definitely not quite on par with classics like "The Tower of the Elephant," but I think it's probably my favorite of the stories that were contributed to by more than just Howard (pastiches and re-edits included). The story isn't deep and it doesn't represent any kind of leap forward for Conan's character; it's just action setpiece after action setpiece. Conan taking his sword in his teeth in order to scurry up the wall of the crypt rules. "As he reached the wall, Conan dropped his buckler, took his sword in his teeth, sprang high in the air, and caught the lower sill of one of the cells in the third tier above the floor, a cell that had already discharged its occupant. With simian agility the Cimmerian mountaineer went up the wall, using the cell openings as hand and foot-holds." I first read this story in the pages of Savage Sword and I think Roy Thomas's version might ultimately be the superior version. The ending is a little too swift, with Conan heading off to Khauran for "A Witch Shall Be Born," which is a classic that I'm excited to re-read. There aren't a ton of markers that place this story firmly in chronology other than the fact that Conan is with the Red Brotherhood and the fact that he's on the Vilayet Sea. I think that where most other Conan chroniclers have put it, after "Iron Shadows in the Moon" and prior to "A Witch Shall Be Born," makes sense. Now, if you look over at our "Chronology" page, you'll see that this is the first story in our "Conan the Barbarian" section, having completed "The Coming of Conan." I'm totally ripping off this labeling convention from the Joe Marek chronology, which is pretty close to mine. That was mostly just to break it up into slightly more digestible fragments (speaking of fragments, I think I'm at the halfway point!), but I don't think it's the best way to divide Conan's career. The way that makes the most sense to me is to divide by the section of Conan's life, because most of them have fit into a clear era so far.
What's in a name, or rather, a title? In my opinion, quite a bit. I wrote briefly when we read "The Lair of the Ice Worm" how that title gave too much away from the story. I gave "The Castle of Terror" a pass, but "Shadows in the Moonlight" confuses me. "Iron Shadows in the Moon," Robert E. Howard's original title for this Conan story, is a fucking banger of a title. It alludes to some of the more exciting aspects of the story (both the black iron statues in the ruins and the gigantic ancient creature who chases Conan and Olivia several times) while also sounding cryptic and interesting. Are the iron shadows being caused by the moon? Are they being cast onto the moon from something on Earth? It's a great title. That's why I find it really lame that between submission and publication time, this story's title was changed and ultimately appeared in the April 1934 edition of Weird Tales as "Shadows in the Moonlight." This isn't the worst title of all time or anything, but it's certainly a step down from the original and feels much more generic. This is probably exacerbated by the fact that the story directly preceding this one in the chronology has almost the same title, "Shadows in the Dark." In fact, there are lots of repetitive titles in this series. There are shadows in the dark, in the moonlight, in Zamboula, in the skull. There are lots of black things: coasts, colossuses, tears, circles, ones in pools, rivers sphinxes. There are red nails, citadels of scarlet, moons of blood, gods with crimson stains... Anyway, Howard penned this story along with two others in November or December 1932, so this is one of the original batch of Conan stories that he pumped out in his first year of the Hyborian Age. The setting of this story is fun, albeit unoriginal. Conan has traveled really far offscreen between the last story and this. He's gone from the port of Messantia in Argos all the way to the Vilayet Sea, close to where he spent most of his days as a Turanian mercenary. The story explicitly tells us that Conan spent some time with raiders impartially plundering Koth, Zamora and Turan between then and now. According to the L. Sprague de Camp introduction in the reprinted version of this story, Conan should be about 30, which makes sense to me. We spend most of this story on an island in the middle of the sea, complete with an ancient ruin untouched for centuries. Those ruins and the black, iron statues in them are tied for the best aspect of the story, I would say. After selling "Black Colossus" to Weird Tales, Howard apparently decided that quality and strong characters were not essential for convincing Farnsworth Wright to buy your story (odd that it's that story that told him that seeing as "Black Colossus" is one of his best) as he banged out this story, "Xuthal of the Dusk" and "The Pool of the Black One" in the next months. Still, this tale has some really fun characterization that I guess Howard just lucked into. Conan's spat with a group of pirates is entertaining and nearly laugh-out-loud funny. They bicker like teenagers and Conan is forced to recount their idiocy: "Crom, what a day it has been! Such haggling and wrangling I never heard. I'm nearly deaf. Aratus wished to cut out my heart, and Ivanos refused, to spite Aratus, whom he hates. All day long they snarled and spat at one another, and the crew quickly grew too drunk to vote either way—" He later makes them beg to get back on their ship, all the while making him captain of them. You can practically hear the ass-kissing as they climb aboard.
"Shadows in the Moonlight" moves fairly quick and the fact that Howard holds off on revealing the monsters for quite some time gives it a solid sense of tension and mystery. Conan ends the story by sailing off into the Vilayet Sea with Olivia on his arm. Olivia says she'll fallow him the world over, but I have a feeling she'll be yesterday's news by the time we see him again. This story feels about as stock as some of its characters- it's far from a bad time, but far from the best either. Up next is "The Road of the Eagles," which I absolutely loved when I read the Roy Thomas Savage Sword adaption, but I've never picked up the original! ★★☆☆☆ What's this? Returning characters in a Conan story? For once, we get to see the characters from a previous story come back for a second round! At least for a little while. And there's a lot of fun to be had in this daring rescue of a king from the dungeons of a foreign city. Following the events of "Black Colossus," Conan is still living a relatively cushy life in Khoraja and has ascended to the post of general of the army. He appears to have been here some months, if not a year, because his continuing romance with princess Yasmela has had time to run its course and begin to sour. Honestly, his relationship with Yasmela in this pair of stories seems much more tender and human than his whirlwind romance with Bêlit back in "Queen of the Black Coast." We also see the return of a minor character, Taurus, though not the thief named Taurus from "The Tower of the Elephant." Conan and the advisors to Yasmela are hoping to avoid a power struggle in the absence of King Khossus, so Conan makes a play to rescue him from the city of Ianthe in central Ophir. Accompanying Conan are the lockpicking master thief Fronto and the fortune-telling Rhazes, who is more skilled in magic than he originally lets on. They feel much like a classic D&D party: your fighter, your rogue, and your sorcerer, each with their own skills and hang-ups. I always love when Conan is forced to work with people he can't entirely trust, and this little band fits the bill well. Fronto is a muttering weirdo with grievances and debts aplenty, while Rhazes seems to be almost too skilled at getting what he wants. Conan can't really relax around either of them, but their time together is fun in that Rhazes is really annoying to Conan. King Khossus's rescue from the dungeons of Ianthe are a fun episode, and I was confused when it was complete with still about three pages to go in the story. It has one of my favorite endings to a Conan tale so far: fed up with Yasmela and the oblivious, privileged assholery of Khossus, Conan decideds to abandon the King. They have secured a ship home and a large sum of money, which Khossus has told Conan to carry as it doesn't befit a king to carry so many gold coins. Conan sticks his hand into the bag and grabs a handful of coins, shoves them in Khossus's hands, and says, "Here. You'll need these to get home," as he jumps back to the dock from the ship, which is rapidly pulling away. He considers the rest to be his payment and bids Khossus to tell Yasmela good bye for him. It's a hilarious ending that perfectly befits Conan. I really enjoyed this story. The adventure is exciting and there are a few twists and turns along the way. The characterization is spot on and keeps the mood up throughout, something that I wish more stories would lean into. I really appreciate when Conan stories are funny, as I spoke of about "Rogues in the House," and there's quite a bit of good humor here.
Conan takes a pretty circuitous route in this story, going from Khoraja around Khorshemish (for reasons I don't want to spoil) to the city of Ianthe. We leave him in Messantia, the port city of Argos that we've been to before. ★★★★☆ 1. Conan is travelling westward on the slopes of the Eiglophian Mountains in "The Lair of the Ice Worm." I know some people put "The Frost-Giant's Daughter" up here as well, but I think that story happens much earlier in the chronology, so it's on our first map.
2. "Queen of the Black Coast" opens on the coast of Argos. Conan is mentioned to have passed through Nemedia, Ophir, and Argos working as a mercenary. Boarding the ship the Argus, he passes the coasts of Shem, Stygia, and Kush. 3. The Argus is beseeched by pirates off the coast of Kush and Conan joins Bêlit aboard the Tigress. They sail up the Zarkheba river together briefly before Bêlit dies in an unnamed ruin of an ancient city. 4. "The Vale of Lost Women" shows Conan working with the Bamula tribe to defeat the Bakalah tribe. Bamula is marked further downriver than Bakalah, so I'm assuming he joined up with the Bamula close to their home territory and moved with them to Bakalah. The end of the story says that Conan takes the captive Livia north to the border of Stygia where she will arrange for transportation home to Ophir. 5. Somewhere in the veldts of Kush, Conan encounters a castle occupied by an evil spirit in "The Castle of Terror." He is there only one night before escaping on a Stygian soldier's horse. 6. Conan arrives in the city of Meroe, also called Shumballah (as it appears on the map I'm marking). He is there for presumably at least a few months as he becomes the captain of the guard and works in close proximity to the queen. He leaves upon the uprising of the lower caste at the end of "The Snout in the Dark." 7. Between "The Snout in the Dark" and as prologue to "Hawks Over Shem," Conan decides to work as a mercenary again, this time for the King Sumuabi of Akkharia. He is the sole survivor of an attack, leading him to Asgalun, the capital. 8. Conan spends "Hawks Over Shem" in Asgalun. 9. In "Black Colossus," Conan becomes a military commander of Khoraja in its capital city, also called Khoraja. Defending it from the evil sorcerer Natohk, he moves with the army to a mountain pass. 10. Conan follows Natohk to the ancient ruin dome of Kutchemes, where he defeats the wizard and the story ends. "Black Colossus" is a really stellar Conan story that has a little bit of everything, and the more I think about it, the more I love this story. It was published in the June 1933 issue of Weird Tales, with a Margaret Brundage painting gracing the cover of princess Yasmela pleading to the god Mitra. Conan has headed far east of Asgalun from "Hawks Over Shem" to the tiny kingdom of Khoraja, and the capital city which shares its name. Conan isn't here long before he leads an army away from the city, through the Pass of Shamla, and then rides alone to Kuthchemes. I've got a new map tracking him up to this point. I have to say, "Black Colossus" does peak a little bit early, but that's not a knock at the rest of the narrative. It opens on the ancient, domed ruin of Kuthchemes, with a master thief named Shevatas hoping to plunder it. The air is tense and the atmosphere of fear is palpable. Truly, it's a tomb raiding scene to match the best of them. Conan isn't introduced until a bit later in the story, after we spend some time with the princess Yasmela. She's not quite a damsel in distress, but she's not as compelling as some of the other Hyborian heroines, either. I always like when we get to spend some time with non-Conan characters: it always helps define the stakes and flesh out the world a bit. We get to hear the voices of the gods for the first time, as Mitra speaks to Yasmela to find the first man she runs into on the street in order to help her save her kingdom. It just so happens to be everyone's favorite Cimmerian. I was talking with someone recently on Reddit about this episode: it seems to me that this is proof of the gods in the Hyborian Age. Mitra not only responds to the prayer, but also tells Yasmela exactly where to find Conan. The commenter was pretty much making the argument that this was a trick of a priest of Mitra, like we'll see in "The Ivory Goddess," with someone throwing their voice from a hidden location, but it seems like a huge leap of faith for that person to tell Yasmela exactly where to go to find Conan. It's too coincidental for me! I found this scene to contain a passage that seems pretty illustrative of Robert E. Howard's personal philosophy. As Yasmela asks Mitra for aid, we get a descriptive passage of the effigy carved of him in a hidden temple beneath her palace:
Most of Howard's stories contain at least some element of distain for cities. It's pretty unsurprising for a Texan author who was so interested in westerns, as this attitude seeps into most of his work. He clearly considers city life less pure, less clean, and less moral than life in the country. A lot of times, this tinges his writing with what we would call the "noble savage" trope today. I often think that he would very much get along with regionalist writers like Willa Cather. The above passage in particular shows a reverence for the unencumbered. A sort of rugged individualism, or artistic state of nature that he seems to yearn for as if to say, If only I could create whatever I liked without having to worry about society's response to anything. "Black Colossus" feels like a real turning point in Conan's journey. For the first time in his life, we see Conan growing to be the shrewd, skilled military commander that would be able to take Aquilonia and become king. He says that he's more careful than usual because it's not only his life on the line, and it's true that this is a more careful Conan than we've ever seen before. It's always seemed to me that Conan is not the best military commander because he's necessarily the smartest or most experienced leader, but because he's the most unflappable. It takes a hell of a lot to rattle Conan of Cimmeria, meaning that he makes few mistakes. There are some real banger lines in this story, one of which shows how Conan thinks of battle. "Conan listened unperturbed. War was his trade. Life was a continual battle, or series of battles, since his birth. Death had been a constant companion. It stalked horrifically at his side; stood at his shoulder beside the gaming-tables; its bony fingers rattled the wine-cups. It loomed above him, a hooded and monstrous shadow, when he lay down to sleep. He minded its presence no more than a king minds the presence of his cupbearer. Some day its bony grasp would close; that was all. It was enough that he lived through the present." Conan gained his panther-like stealth skills in the thief stories. He learned military ways and horsemanship in the Turanian army. He got his sea legs in "Queen of the Black Coast." He's now learning to command and strategize. It's a real pleasure to follow this chronology fully and see him become, you know, Conan a bit at a time. According to "A Probable Outline of Conan's Career", Conan "may be about 27. I've used this essay as a tool to help map his career, but I would like to say that I'm not treating it as gospel truth- if I did, there wouldn't be much point in me trying to map out these stories. That essay's authors do note that King Yildiz of the Turanian empire seems to have died around some point here, being replaced by King Yezdigerd, who gets mentioned so incredibly often in stories following this. You know how sometimes a person might be your best friend but then you realize you're not their best friend? It definitely seems like King Yezdigerd is not Conan's arch nemesis, but Conan is King Yezdigerd's arch nemesis. "Black Colossus" fucks. Part of me wishes that we got to see more of the villain, but that feeling also goes away when we finally get to see him riding a chariot, pulled by some kind of black camel demon, driven by some kind of black ape demon, and there stands Thugra Khotan on the back of it. There are clear stakes, Conan is badass, the villain is menacing, the setpieces are epic, and the pacing is very solid. This might be one of the most well-rounded adventure stories I've ever read. I like to think that Roy Thomas agrees with me about how good this one is, since he didn't waste any time adapting it to Savage Sword, with it appearing as just the second issue complete with one of the best Savage Sword covers of all time. It's probably not the best Conan story of all time, but it's certainly in my top 3 (up there with "The Tower of the Elephant" and "Queen of the Black Coast" as of now. In fact, I think when I'm done with this chronology, I'll rank all the Howard-written stories. Next time, we're reading "Shadows in the Dark," which I've never read an adaption of, nor have I ever even heard anyone discuss the story if I remember right. We'll see how it compares to today's epic. In the early Spring of 1933, Conan the Cimmerian had hit something of a low point, at least in the mind of his writer, Robert E. Howard. Howard had written a dozen of them, but only three had made it to publication, so he was yet to see what a smash hit his barbarian would be. None of the stories had graced the cover of the magazine. Howard's agent, Otis Kline, was encouraging REH to diversify his portfolio a bit to keep the cash flowing. Howard, who was already very interested in western and boxing stories, didn't need a ton of convincing. He wouldn't return to writing Conan stories for several months. During this period away from the Hyborian Age, he tried his hand at writing a novel several times and even banged out about 5000 words a day, 7 days a week, for a time. He tried to sell collections of his short stories, and he wrote in other genres. One of the books he wrote during this time was a novella of political intrigue that was set in Cairo, Egypt, among factions vying for power. It was called Hawks Over Egypt. Kline received the Hawks Over Egypt from Howard on October 23rd, 1933, and it didn't go out to the publishers for one reason or another. In August 1935, Kline received a rewrite of the story and submitted it to the magazine Argosy. They rejected it. He sent it to Blue Book in January of 1936. They rejected it. He sent it to Complete Stories in April. They rejected it. The next day he sent it off to Short Stories. They rejected it. He didn't send it out again. For the next twenty years, Hawks Over Egypt sat in a trunk with everything else Robert E. Howard failed to publish during his short lifetime. In the early 1950s, that trunk was accessed by L. Sprague de Camp and Lin Carter, who picked through to find unpublished Conan stories. They pulled out eight fragments or outlines of Conan material, but with it they found four unpublished stories that weren't set in the Hyborian Age. In 1953, publisher Martin Greenberg suggested that they be turned into Conan tales. de Camp rewrote them with Conan as the central character, "by changing names, deleting anachronisms, and introducing a supernatural element." It wasn't hard, he said, "since Howard's heroes were pretty much all cut from the same cloth." One of those stories was Hawks Over Egypt, which became "Hawks Over Shem," and was first published in the collection Conan the Freebooter in 1968. As such, the story is credited to both Howard and de Camp. Conan the Freebooter is up on the Internet Archive for free and I really owe a beer to whoever uploaded all these books, because I've been reading entirely for free. In "Hawks Over Shem," Conan has decided to make some dough at what he's usually been best at: mercenary work in Shem. After his whole army is wiped out, we find him in Asgalun looking for revenge. The story has a great opening and it's a pretty decent adventure: there's lots and lots of political intrigue, assassinations, secret passageways, cleaved body parts... I still think we're on a bit of an upswing from the low point of "The Vale of Lost Women" and filler of "The Castle of Terror," but the story isn't top-notch. This is partially because it has so many names of one-off characters or other vocabulary terms to learn. I tried to keep track as I read and came up with Asgalun, Akhirom, Anakim, Abibaal, Abdashtarth, Othbaal, Zeriti, Pelishita, Imbalayo, Farouz, Mazdak, Rufia, Mattenbaal, Bombaata, Keluka, and Khannon. I'm usually pretty quick on the uptake for those sorts of things, but I found myself struggling with which of the characters whose names start with "A" were which. I read Roy Thomas's version of this story prior in Savage Sword #36 and found it to be vastly superior. The original Hawks Over Egypt did eventually see publication, in the collection called The Road of Azrael in 1979. I've noticed that now that Conan is at the very least in his mid-20s, the stories don't often point out that he is young anymore. He seems to finally be solidly in the period that we think of as prime Conan. His skill is unmatched, his cunning and maturity are growing, and he's much more well-traveled. Next time, in "Black Colossus," we're leaving Shem, but we won't go far. We're headed to the tiny nation of Khoraja, which I don't think we've seen referenced in any other Conan story so far. Chronologically speaking, I really appreciate that this section of stories has featured only small moves at a time. Conan is spending a story or two in every nation, moving only one country at a time, in a general direction of coming back up north from the Black Kingdoms. Sometimes the chronologies move him really far between stories (like when he goes from Khitai all the way back below the Vilayet sea to the Hyborian kingdoms again), and that always feels like maybe there's a better way to sort them, but I can't think of one. These fit together nicely. ★★★☆☆ After a couple of mediocre tales, "The Snout in the Dark" is somewhat of a return to form. It is, at the very least, much more entertaining than most of Conan's adventures in Kush. I get the sense that I like this one more than some other folks. At the end of "The Castle of Terror," Conan stole a horse and some articles of armor from a Stygian, which he arrives to this story clad in. He's made it to the kingdom of Kush proper, which the story says he and other northerners sometimes refer to all of the "black kingdoms" as. He's been moving northward since leaving the evil castle in the veldt. This story fits very well exactly where it's traditionally been put by other chronologies: between "The Castle of Terror" and before "Hawks Over Shem." It has to take place after his time as a pirate, because the events of "Queen of the Black Coast" are explicitly mentioned. There are a decent number of Conan stories that are built around political intrigue, and I think that depending on how they're handled, they can be some of the best or some of the worst. For example, Conan the Liberator is basically all politicking and spies and plans to usurp, but it keeps Conan stuck in military camps and in fields, so it kills any sense of adventure. This one is a little better. We are in the city of Meroë, which is divided into a rigid caste system based on race. As you might have guessed for REH, the dark-skinned Kushites are on the bottom, with the lighter-skinned ruling class (which he calls "dusky." Can you just be normal about skin color for once, Howard?) above them. Members of the ruling class are trying to worm their way to the top through assassinations and spies and framing one another for crimes, all the while worrying about angering the populace as a whole and risking an overthrow. Conan complicates all of this on arrival because he's loyal to the queen, Tananda (at least insofar as she's paying him well), but he's also very popular among the other mechanisms of power, so he kind of has to be stepped around. Though this story is once again weird and off-putting when it comes to race, I was really glad to see that the lower caste ends the story by essentially rising up in revolution. "Slay alll the lords! Cast off your bonds! Kill the masters! Be free men again and not slaves! Kill, kill, kill!" I think that's just about the best ending we could hope for in a story like this. I read both the original rough draft by Howard in my copy of The Complete Chronicles of Conan, as well as the de Camp & Carter rewrite in Conan of Cimmeria, and this time I vastly prefer the rewrite. It doesn't seem that there's any information about when in the 30s Howard began "Snout in the Dark," but it was never published originally until the rewrite made its debut in 1969. Conan has continued to grow and is, for once, perhaps the most interesting character in the story. He has pretty much matured to the point of knowing when it's advantageous to hold his tongue. "'I am a wanderer,' [Conan] said simply, 'with a sword for hire. I came here to seek my fortune.' He did not think it wise to tell her of his previous career as a corsair on the Black Coast, or of his chieftainship of one of the jungle tribes to the south." As a longtime D&D player, Conan comes off as very lawful neutral in this story. While he has his own code of honor, he's only working with the ruling class as it benefits him, and is completely ready to throw off those bonds when it's expedient for him.
The pig-ape-demon thing of the title is a fun monster (though not everyone seems to think so), but I like that it's a physical match for Conan, unlike most enemies that aren't literally giant monsters. They do battle inside his temporary home, with lightning flashing through the windows to illuminate his pig tusks. I thought it was pretty cool, anyway. Conan ends this story by riding north once again. He says that he's done with the southern kingdoms and might even take another crack at civilization. I'm now 20 stories into this chronology! Thanks for following me on it if you've been reading! "Hawks Over Shem" is up next, so I assume we'll be going to the kingdom of Shem. ★★★☆☆ People like to talk shit online about the title of this story, calling it generic. I'm not going to say they're wrong, but I'm a big fan of old horror movies and I have to say that I've seen dozens of horror movies from the 50s and 60s with titles just as generic that were really fun. I always enjoy when Conan stories focus on the horror, and while this story is a lesser one, I thought it was decent, if forgettable. I think anime fans would refer to this one as a "filler episode." "The Castle of Terror" was written by L. Sprague de Camp and Lin Carter in 1969. It follows directly from "The Vale of Lost Women" as Conan is headed back toward cities out of the jungle when he finds himself on a massive grassland. Forced by pursuing lions to seek respite in a creepy castle on the plain, Conan stays the night astrally-projecting and sort of communing with spirits. The astral projection part is unique. Conan is suddenly privy to knowledge without knowing how he knows it, and it adds some suspense as we hear the intentions of a thousand and one ancient ghosts which mean to do him harm, but first have to manifest physically. Matters get complicated when Stygians show up, also seeking shelter from a storm. We get a bit of a standoff where Conan is deciding whether to try his luck with the Stygians or focus on the blob of ancient ghost stuff. The descriptions feel gothic and menacing, which add some Howardesque (Howardian?) prose to the narrative. We also get numerous references to the castle being as old as King Kull of Valusia, and that's always welcome in a Conan story.
This story features almost no dialogue. I only realized about halfway through that I didn't think Conan had actually said anything so far (after all, it was just him, lions, and ghosts so far), but he hadn't so much as opened his mouth to take Crom's name in vain. The whole thing is almost completely silent until a Stygian starts screaming at the end. It kind of reminded me of an issue of Amazing Spider-Man I read as a kid called "Nuff Said," which didn't have a single word in it. Gary at Sprague de Camp Fan, who I enjoy reading along with many of these posts, notes that Conan comic GOATs Roy Thomas and John Buscema were both very uninspired by this portion of Conan's career. Same. For this story in particular, it's mostly just lacking flavor. Conan's path is generally one that's headed north. We'll still be in Kush next time in "The Snout in the Dark." ★★☆☆☆ Well, here it is. The first one-star review I'm putting on a Conan story and the absolute worst one so far. In February of 1933, about a month after selling "Rogues in the House" to Weird Tales, Robert E. Howard was feeling a little bit burned out on the Conan character. In the course of a year since his trip to Mission, Texas where he first envisioned Cimmeria and then stories just poured out of him, involuntarily, if he's to be believed, about this barbarian creation, he had penned twelve Conan tales. Nine of them he sold to Weird Tales, but only three of them had made it to print. Howard had a burgeoning interest in writing western stories during this time, and apparently noted that the Depression was hitting his industry hard, was hoping to diversify his storytelling. According to "Hyborian Genesis," Patrice Louinet says that we can probably trace "The Vale of Lost Women" back to one pen pal of Howard's, who told him a story about white Texans getting captured by Native Americans in the 1830s: “In 1836, when the Texans were fighting for their freedom, the Comanches were particularly bold in raiding the scattered settlements, and it was in one of those raids that Fort Parker fell. Seven hundred Comanches and Kiowas literally wiped it off the earth, with most of its inhabitants. . . . Fort Parker passed into oblivion, and among the women and children taken captive were Cynthia Anne Parker, nine years old, and her brother John, a child of six. Louinet hypothesizes that Howard was trying to imbue his story with the themes of many westerns: about the dangers of the frontier. He feels that those themes were lost in translation to the fantasy setting. What we're left with, according to Louinet, is "unsettling reading." I'll go a step further and call it an irredeemably racist excuse for a fantasy story. I agree with Louinet that Howard missed when it came to writing a "weird western," but what he managed to do was imbue this story with every "going native" anxiety that white people had held since colonial America. We saw it in The Last of the Mohicans in 1757, we saw it in the film The Birth of a Nation in 1915, and it's alive and well in "The Vale of Lost Women" in 1933. I'm not being hyperbolic about this- every description of black characters in this story is pretty horrifically racist. By the time Conan says, "I am not such a dog as to leave a white woman in the clutches of a black man," I was just about ready to be done. Even from just a literary perspective, I find stories like this to be of unacceptably low quality. Howard, who has proven time and again to be able to be able to whisk us away to lands undreamed of, he can't imagine a black culture not completely infected by his own vile views. Howard frequently uses skin color as a shorthand for goodness. White is purity and morality, and darker skin sits on a spectrum of immoral to straight-up subhuman. I haven't ever read the Roy Thomas Marvel Comics adaption of this story, and I would be interested to. Sometimes Thomas very subtly sands off some of the rougher edges of Howard. I'm genuinely not trying to put Howard's racism front-and-center in these posts, mostly because I'm trying to have a good time by reading and writing about one of my favorite fictional characters, but this story makes it impossible to ignore. I often see hand-waving about the racism of the time. "It was the 30s, what do you expect?" I don't think we have to accept that. My grandfather told me a story once about how a kid in town called one of his only black classmates the n-word when they were in school. My grandpa and some other kids beat the shit out of him, and "He didn't say that word no more," according to my grandpa. That was in the early 40s. The only good thing about this story is that it is told from the perspective of the girl Livia entirely, which makes it a little unique in the Conan canon. After burning Bêlit's ship the Tigress upon her death, Conan has been living in Kush and making a name for himself with his fighting strength. He's farther south than he's ever been on the map. Howard took a break of a few months to write stories that had nothing to do with Conan after this one. There's no record that he ever submitted it to Weird Tales, and it was published for the first time in Magazine of Horror in 1967. Horrifying indeed. If only this slop had stayed in trunk. "The Castle of Terror" is up next. Sounds cool! ★☆☆☆☆ I have a sort of treasured memory when it comes to "Queen of the Black Coast," if you'll indulge me. In the summer of 2015, my wife (still my girlfriend at the time) and I had just moved back home to Colorado after a few years of living in Florida. Since I'm a teacher, I was on summer break, but my wife was working at a veterinary office and since she didn't have a car at the moment, I was driving her to work in the mornings. I dropped her off at work, and, realizing I had absolutely nothing to do with the whole rest of the day, drove to the Barnes & Noble on Pearl Street in Boulder and decided to bum around among the shelves for a while. I saw a thick volume of The Complete Chronicles of Conan and picked it up since I had read a few issues of Savage Sword recently and had a very budding interest in the big guy. For some reason, I had it in my head that "Queen of the Black Coast" was the first Conan story (it's not, but I didn't yet have a smartphone to look that up on the fly) so I flipped to the middle of the book and started reading. The story absolutely flew by, and while I meant to just check out the first couple of pages, I accidentally read the whole thing. When I looked up, sitting in the back corner of the store with big, south-facing windows and the morning light streaming in probably just after 8, I was pretty enraptured. I was also feeling very, very at peace. I bought the book and skipped around in it a little bit more that day. I think I read "Black Colossus" next, and then "The Phoenix on the Sword." "Queen of the Black Coast" was published in the May 1934 issue of Weird Tales, and as the cover story it has a painting that doesn't look anything like Conan or Bêlit. This story kind of sneaks up on you, in a way. It's not the flashiest of all Conan tales, but, and I reserve the right to change my mind on this as I read further, it might be the best-written of all Conan stories. The story begins in medias res with Conan fleeing the guards of Argos, where he clamors aboard a ship and demands safe passage. It's an exciting beginning that wastes no time, not that Howard usually does. The Argus (yes, the Argus is docked in Argos) is quickly beseeched by pirates and Conan meets the first real love of his life, Bêlit. Bêlit is certainly a fun character to spend some time with; she's like the pirate version of a pulp noir femme fatale, and she perfectly matches Conan's intensity. It's not like the two have long adventures in which we see them fall in love, but- to use the language of a current meme- they match each other's freak. But, not to take anything away from her, I think the best thing about this story is what Bêlit brings out in Conan. "'Conan, let us go and sack that city!' First of all, Conan seems happy. When I was writing about "The Hand of Nergal," I mentioned two parts about a wistful love of adventure that felt shoehorned in at the time. However, here, the feeling really seems earned. Everett F. Blieler, a midcentury fiction editor, said, "Queen of the Black Coast" was "probably the best of the Conan stories, perhaps because it is the only one based on another emotion than lust, greed, or hatred." I'm inclined to agree with him here (maybe not the best, but one of the best, for the same reason he said). The tone of the novel is somehow easier, without losing any of the excitement that you want in a sword-and-sorcery story. The other aspect that's really enjoyable is that Conan opens up to someone in ways we've never seen. "'What of your own gods? I have never heard you call on them.' Particularly, I like the above line because it outlines something Conan is usually sketchy about. Sure, he swears by Crom in nearly every story, but does Conan believe in Crom? Does he worship Crom? The answers are apparently a yes and a no. "Let me live deep while I live; let me know the rich juices of red meat and stinging wine on my palate, the hot embrace of white arms, the mad exultation of battle when the blue blades flame and crimson, and I am content. Let teachers and priests and philosophers brood over questions of reality and illusion. I know this: if life is illusion, then I am no less an illusion, and being thus, the illusion is real to me. I live, I burn with life, I love, I slay, and am content." This reads like manifesto for the Conan books themselves. To borrow from the Arnold Schwarzenegger movie, it's like asking Conan, "What is best in life?" To burn with life, love, slay, be content. I don't want to imply that all pulp writing is subpar, far from it, but most of these stories were written as escapist tales for boys to read during the depression, if we're being honest. "Queen of the Black Coast" is so well-put-together that I forget that while reading it. It is absolutely bogged down by some more of Howard's weird, racist attitudes toward Black characters (Must they always be referred to as "blacks?" Once again, how about "the pirates" or "the crew" or even just "the men?") and his anti-Semitism creeping in at the edges if you examine how he describes Shemites. I don't want to be hyperbolic and say that it's a perfect story. When Bêlit saves Conan at the end of the story, it's an all-timer. I only wish that Howard hadn't killed Bêlit in the same story in which she was introduced. I would love for more buccaneer stories to be the continuing adventures of Conan of Cimmeria and Bêlit of the sea. In terms of our chronology, I understand that it's the first of what people refer to as the pirate stories, but I think most of those are from novels or elsewhere, so we won't see more of a sea-borne Conan coming up, at least not for a while. Conan is really far south right now, and he'll spend the next several stories working his way back north, so in my head, I'm kind of thinking of this next set as his "Goin' Down South" period. Conan has moved a long way already from the end of "The Lair of the Ice Worm" to the opening of "Black Coast:" in the prologue that was probably added by L. Sprague de Camp to the collection Conan of Cimmeria, Conan has dipped down from the snows through Nemedia, Ophir, and Argos working as a mercenary, and his clothing at the beginning of the story reflects that. For all of Howard's regressive, backwards views on race, he sure makes Conan look rad as hell with his multicultural garb: "His horned helmet was such as was worn by the golden-haired Æsir of Nordheim; his hauberk and greaves were of the finest workmanship of Koth; the fine ring-mail which sheathed his arms and legs was of Nemedia; the blade at his girdle was a great Aquilonian broadsword; and his gorgeous scarlet cloak could have been spun nowhere but in Ophir." Because the story only mentions the countries that he passed through, we don't have an exact path, but it's pretty much just a southeasterly trajectory. While aboard the ships the Argus and the Tigress, Conan hugs the borders of Shem, Stygia, and Kush. They travel up the Zarkheba River together.
Conan is about 24. Up next is "The Vale of Lost Women," which I've never read in any form. ★★★★★ |
AuthorHey, I'm Dan. This is my project reading through the career of everyone's favorite sword-and-sorcery character, Conan the Cimmerian, in chronological order. Archives
September 2024
Categories |